ABOUT THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT   |    THE IMPACT    |    SOLUTIONS AND ALTERNATIVES
TAKE ACTION   |    SUPPORT THE CAUSE    |   PRESS AND OPINION    |   CONTACT US
Save the Lakes is now a member of the Shawangunk Ridge Coalition.

OCTOBER 29: DEC PUBLIC SCOPING SESSION OPENS QUESTIONS

CONCERNED CITIZENS SPEAK OUT

Comments Enter the Public Record


CLICK HERE TO REVIEW SAVE THE LAKES
SCOPING COMMENTS SUBMITTED TO THE DEC


Special thanks go out to the Biodiversity Partnership for their submission,
and to Paul Rubin for his expert hydrological analysis,
both of which are not yet included here.
OCTOBER 29: DEC PUBLIC SCOPING SESSION OPENS QUESTIONS


IMP0RTANT ANNOUNCEMENTS:
On July 2, 2008: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation Commissioner Pete Grannis named DEC Region 3 office as lead agency for the SEQRA review process.

On August 4, DEC sent out SEQR Positive Declaration (DEC No. 3-5146-00063/00007) outlining 16 major impacts of concern to be addressed in the scoping process.

On September 17, 2008 the DEC issued a Draft Scoping Document for a Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) an important 20 page, detailed document.
IMPORTANT CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD A PDF OF THE DEC SEPTEMBER 17, 2008 DRAFT SCOPING DOCUMENT FOR A DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT (DEIS)

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD A PDF OF THE DEC AUGUST 4, 2008 SEQR POSITIVE DECLARATION OUTLINING 16 MAJOR IMPACTS OF CONCERN TO BE ADDRESSED IN THE SCOPING PROCESS

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD A PDF OF DEC COMMISSIONER GRANNIS' DECISION TO NAME DEC REGION 3 AS LEAD AGENCY

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD A PDF OF DEC REGIONAL DIRECTOR JANEWAY'S 01/04/08 LETTER TO THE TOWN OUTLINING THE REASONS THAT DEC REQUESTED LEAD AGENCY STATUS

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD A PDF OF DEC REGIONAL DIRECTOR JANEWAY'S FOLLOW-UP LETTER DATED 02/11/08 ANSWERING CONCERNS EXPRESSED BY ROSENDALE TOWN OFFICIALS ON THE LEAD AGENCY ISSUE

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD A PDF OF ATTORNEY ED WILLIAMS' LETTER TO COMMISSIONER GRANNIS THAT DETAILS THE HISTORY AND PHYSICAL FEATURES OF WILLIAMS LAKE ALONG WITH AN EXHAUSTIVE ANALYSIS OF HRVR'S DEVELOPMENT PLAN

PLEASE BE ADVISED that citizens who wish their opinion to be known on this issue should send a letter to the Town Supervisor, Mr. Pat McDonough, Town Hall, P.O. Box 423, Rosendale, NY 12472, with a copy to the Regional Director of DEC Region III, Mr. Willie Janeway, at the DEC office in New Paltz, and whose mailing address is 21 South Putt Corners Road, New Paltz, NY 12561-1696.   DON'T BE APATHETIC.



JOIN OUR EMAIL LIST - to keep abreast of news on this important subject - to join your neighbors in working to preserve the wildlife, open space and character of our town and region - all in the spirit of greater prosperity and a better quality of life.

(Please note that if you've already joined, but have not been seeing regular updates from us, make sure that your address book contains an entry for SaveTheLakes@gmail.com, so our messages are not discarded by your spam filters. Thanks!)


SAVE THE LAKES MISSION STATEMENT
To protect the natural resources of all the land included in the Williams Lake property and preserve it in perpetuity for the region. We work to insure that the future of Rosendale is planned in concert with community needs and values. We research information and provide data to the public and to area decision-makers.


 
CANOPY/HRVR HAS PROPOSED A ZONING AMENDMENT THAT WOULD NOT ONLY ALLOW THEIR PROJECT TO PROCEED, BUT WOULD ALSO ESTABLISH DEVELOPMENT CRITERIA FOR THE TOWN AS A WHOLE.

IMPORTANT CLICK TO DOWNLOAD ANALYSIS AND CONCERNS REGARDING THE PROPOSED "SPECIAL PERMIT COMMUNITY."

CLICK TO DOWNLOAD CANOPY/HRVR's SUBMISSION LETTER
CLICK TO DOWNLOAD THE CANOPY/HRVR's ZONING PETITION
CLICK TO DOWNLOAD AMENDMENT EXHIBIT D
CLICK TO DOWNLOAD THE DRAFT SCOPING DOC
 


CANOPY/HRVR's PROJECT AND PROPOSED ZONING TEXT AMENDMENT MUST BE CONSIDERED IN LIGHT OF POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE IMPACTS ON THE ENVIRONMENT AND THE ECONOMY, AND THE MANY QUESTIONS THAT REMAIN UNANSWERED:

TAXES:   There is NO reason to assume that property taxes would go down over the long term. In fact, the opposite has proven true over time for towns subjected to similar resort/real estate development projects that rely upon real-estate sales for the bulk of their profit. Nearly always, as well, the locals are priced out of the market, and forced to relocate.

EUREKA, MONEY IN THE TOWN COFFERS: The hidden costs - economically, socially and environmentally - to the Town of Rosendale are unknown and will remain so for years to come. Looking ahead to a windfall in property tax revenue based on the promises of an unproven developer (during a recession) is wishful thinking, not sound fiscal planning.

WHO WILL PAY, AND HOW MUCH? The tax relationship of the development community to the town is unspecified, but indications are that tax revenue would funnel to the town through a single corporate entity or resort management company (not individual home owners) - a situation that creates power and leverage for the "special permit community", especially one with revenues that dwarf that of the Town. Rosendale's annual fight with the Iron Mountain Corporation over property assessments should serve as a warning: wouldn't the corporate management of this proposed development work to keep it's tax burden to the town at a minimum? Isn't that just good business?

WILDLIFE AND HABITAT:   The proposed development would dramatically disturb and alter the habitat of many species, some of which are endangered.

FACT:   Plans include a luxury destination resort spa and hotel, as well as 160 luxury homes and townhouses.

FACT:   By definition, the development will be a gated community.

FACT:   The proposed development would use 160,000 gallons of water per day, a 900% increase of water use from the Binnewater aquifer.

JOBS?   450 "on-site" workers are mentioned. It is common practice in the global resort business for resort workers to be contracted in from elsewhere, for jobs as diverse as housekeeping to management.

COMMUNITY HOUSING SHORTAGE?   An influx of workers seeking rental accomodations could inflate the cost of local rental housing significantly, should on-site housing not be provided.

GROWTH?   Rosendale's population could increase by 10 percent.

POLITICS?   A corporate enclave of the super-rich could become the new political bosses of Rosendale.

FACT:   Open space will be developed and all affordable public access will be denied. The area will be restricted and off limits:
no swimming, no hiking, no fishing, no canoeing, no cross-country skiing, no caving, no mountain biking...

LOOKING AHEAD:   There are proven alternative solutions that if pursued could preserve this property as both a viable tax-paying business and an asset to the community as a whole. The project as currently proposed creates an exclusive, restricted enclave for the wealthy.

COMMUNICATE:   WITH OUR TOWN OFFICIALS - LET THEM KNOW YOUR CONCERN!

CLICK HERE TO ACCESS DETAILED BACKGROUND INFORMATION ON THE CANOPY/HRVR PROJECT
COMPILED BY CHRISTOPHER BEALL




PLEASE MAKE A DONATION

This is a volunteer effort - help us pay our expenses for printing costs, signs, posters, internet...

Through the auspices of Friends of the Shawangunks YOUR DONATION IS FULLY TAX-DEDUCTIBLE.

MAKE A SECURE DONATION BY CREDIT CARD
Remember to designate your donation for Save The Lakes.





DONATE BY CHECK OR MONEY ORDER:
You can make a 501(c)(3) deductible charitable contribution by sending a check or money order for ANY amount you can
made out to:
Friends of the Shawangunks
and mail it to
Save the Lakes   P.O. Box 153   Rosendale, N.Y. 12472-0153
Please note Save the Lakes as a memo on your check, and be sure your address is on the check for year-end tax purposes. THANK YOU!

CONTRIBUTE WHAT YOU CAN

ROSENDALE AND THE PEOPLE OF ULSTER COUNTY HAVE A CHOICE TO MAKE

ABOUT THE PROPOSED DEVELOPMENT   |    THE IMPACT    |    SOLUTIONS AND ALTERNATIVES
TAKE ACTION   |    SUPPORT THE CAUSE    |   PRESS AND OPINION    |   CONTACT US
Save the Lakes is now a member of the Shawangunk Ridge Coalition.